Stuck on a passage
September 28, 2018 at 7:41 AM #65413
Don’t know why I can’t seem to decode this little double stop passage at ~2:40, but any help would be greatly appreciated.September 28, 2018 at 7:49 AM #65414
Oh my gosh that is really beautiful! The whole thing is pretty complicated, lines going in different directions, etc. Is it in B-flat, or am I seeing that wrong…the guitar, etc.? Have you worked out the rest of it, Dave? This would be a great lesson…lol. Tough one. Beautiful. Reminds me of all the stuff in Gardenia Waltz or Maiden’s Prayer…these lessons on here…it’s so hard to make that kinda stuff sound as beautiful as this feller here is doing. I know you’re good at playing that style, Dave…i hope you get it figured out and play it for us before long.
September 28, 2018 at 8:20 AM #65418
- This reply was modified 1 year, 5 months ago by cricket.
I believe I posted me playing this tune last Winter…But I have plans of re-recording several things I’ve posted to check for improvement or disintegration.
Yes it is in Bb…I’ve been working quite a bit in Bb and F this last year.
I sort of learned my version between this and a Kenny Baker recording.
The song isn’t as hard as it might look really (except of course for all the double stops…heheSeptember 28, 2018 at 1:22 PM #65421
Can’t get any help from the song book because it’s written in Ab. To do what Blaine is doing, at that level, you need to practice corded scales, and double stop runs like in the Carol Wheeler fiddle warm ups book. They will get you there…it’s amazing.
If you can do the math on the cords this book would help figure them out. It’s got a hundred pages of cords. (click on the thumbnail for full size)September 28, 2018 at 1:40 PM #65422
The problem isn’t so much not being able to figure out things…it’s more that I can’t seem to hear what he’s doing clearly, and can’t pick out the notesSeptember 28, 2018 at 3:14 PM #65423Hakan LindholmParticipant
I find an application called “Transcribe” from Seventhstrings very useful when I am trying to analyse audio music. There are plenty of slow downer apps out there. The special thing about “Transcribe” is that it has some very useful tools to aid when trying to hear and analyse what is being played.
One of the most useful tool is the graphical “selection” just to mark up the specific passage one wants to analyse and make it play repeatedly over that passage with various slow down speeds until one can hear the notes or can play along to find each single note and have them match. I find the selection tool very useful. It can reduce the selection down to cover a single note in time and to have that repeated until I have found it on the fiddle and written it down. Another useful tool is for analysing rythm and timing, one can mark upp the song with each beat and bar to get beat markers and bars over the song/selection. This simplifies when trying to find out the length of the notes and rythm pattern. It also suggests the notes and frequensies as well as provide the slowed down videos if it is a video file with music that is played. It also have some filter function to help extract the notes.
A full version is available for a 30 days trial.September 28, 2018 at 5:56 PM #65425
took me 3 hours two computers and several softwares to get the lick to loop in Transcribe but it did work nice.
I found the note thing to be useless, but the fidelity is better than in ASD…
I believe I have it figured out now…not sure if it’s how Blaine did it, but I think it will fit!
sloppy & out of tune but it’s close…September 28, 2018 at 8:13 PM #65430
Great job, Dave! Sounds pretty good to me…I wish I could do that kinda stuff…maybe someday…guess I’ll need to practice…lol. Anyway, very good…you got it…sounds nice.September 28, 2018 at 9:00 PM #65431
Thanks Peggy…Hearing the notes clearly made it fairly easy to figure out…it’s just hard for me to play now…hahaSeptember 29, 2018 at 12:19 AM #65433
Thanks for putting that song up Dave. That group did a great job and it will definitely be on my list. I don’t think I’ll attempt to duplicate all of their cords exactly as they did it though. As long as the harmony sounds good with the melody, I don’t think I”ll worry about it, unless a particular stop has a special sound I can’t do without. There’s usually an intuitive double stop that works fine, but sometimes there’s a special one you have to have.September 29, 2018 at 12:38 AM #65434
Here is Kenny Baker doing it in 1976.September 29, 2018 at 7:16 AM #65441
You’re welcome Roger.
Having different choices on how to play things makes it an adventure.
I wanted this passage mostly because I hear possibilities of other places it could be used. Also, I just liked the lick and couldn’t leave it alone until I found it…haha.September 29, 2018 at 8:42 AM #65444
YEs, that’s the best part…some licks are so cool and then when applied in other places they are new and fresh.September 29, 2018 at 12:23 PM #65446AngelaParticipant
Nice work Dave. Beautiful song but tough!!September 29, 2018 at 2:22 PM #65448
Once you get into it this is really not a high difficulty song, but it does have a couple spots that challenged me for sure.September 29, 2018 at 7:46 PM #65454John (BGD)Keymaster
Dave that’s a great version. I’m attaching my take on the lick…September 29, 2018 at 9:49 PM #65457
I like how yours has the economy of movement in the hand…easier to do quicker when needed. (and happens to be the way Blaine played it )
I had considered using the Last two DS you wrote, but ended up with lower thing I did.
Kind of have to whip myself into hitting that double open string though, even with it being way easier than changing strings with two fingers at once. If i thought more like a real fiddler I’d have probably gone to the open strings right away, but for some reason I have the need to hear a leading tone on that beat.
ha, now I have two ways to do it!
Just don’t know why I make things so hard to do in the first place…grrrrSeptember 30, 2018 at 12:21 PM #65464
Windows doesn’t give you an option to ‘print’ out that lick. What you have to do is right click on it and choose ‘open in new window’. When in the new window it gives you the option to print it out.September 30, 2018 at 12:52 PM #65465
This piece has some complex stuff going on in the psychology of the effects of the cords leading the feelings of the listener into the next cords. I just read a fascinating article on that topic. One point, among many, is how ‘silence’ can be used to great effect. I see that in Blaines rendition, where he plays the first phrase and then there is a sustained hold of several beats, and at exactly 0:55 one beat of silence. The cords leading up to that set a mood and the beat controls the timing of the mood, so the listener feels very comfortable knowing when everything will develop. The beat of silence gives you a chance to take a breath and absorb it all before the next phrase.
From there on, Blaine seems to be a little uncertain what to do with that point when it comes around again each time, and he has a tendency to want to fill it in with some ornamentation. When Kenny plays it, he seems to exploit the effects of the cord so carefully that he can use that silent beat to more effect, but he certainly uses a lot of ornamentation to great effect. Too complex for me to analyze, I just know there’s a lot going on and I wish I really did understand more of it. I do know that the player has to take the time to feel it out when playing it.September 30, 2018 at 1:38 PM #65466
There’s a lot of difference in playing live and recoding in a studio also.
Studio recordings arguably consist more of rehearsed material, where live settings may tend toward more improvisation.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.